Oyster Bay, NY Insurance Agencies – Make the Right Choice

When finding a licensed insurance agent in Oyster Bay, it’s recommended you start your research for an agent online instead of making phone calls. Consumers require a decent agent, but also the best possible rates.

There are many car insurance agents to buy insurance from, and although it’s nice to have a choice, so many choices can make it hard to locate the cheapest rates.

Comparing rates from local agents

Insurance agents can help determine the best coverages and give you peace of mind. The biggest benefit of getting online price quotes is you can get lower rates but still work with a licensed agent.

For easy comparison, once you complete this quick form, your information is immediately sent to agents in your area who will return price quotes to get your business. You won’t need to even leave your home due to the fact that quote results will go to your email. Now that’s easy! It’s the lowest rates and a licensed agent to work with.

Choosing an insurance agency needs to be determined by more than just the premium amount. These are valid questions to ask:

  • Which insurance companies are they affiliated with?
  • Do they have advanced training designations such as CPCU, AAI, AIC, or CIC?
  • How are they compensated?
  • What insurance company do they write the most business with?
  • If you are a high risk driver, do they have special markets for your coverage?
  • How much will you save each year by using a higher deductible?
  • How long has their agency been in business in Oyster Bay?
  • Does the agency have a good rating with the Better Business Bureau?

Types of insurance agencies in Oyster Bay

When researching local Oyster Bay agents, there are a couple of types of agencies to choose from. Agencies in Oyster Bay are either independent (non-captive) or captive.

Agency Captives

Captive agents can only place business with one company and some examples include Liberty Mutual, Allstate, Farmers Insurance or State Farm. Captives cannot provide prices from multiple companies so they have to upsell other benefits. Captive agents receive extensive training on their company’s products and that can be a competitive advantage. Some people will only purchase coverage from captives partially due to loyalty to the company and the convenience of having a single billing for all their coverages.

Below is a short list of captive insurance agents in Oyster Bay willing to provide comparison quotes.

  • Allstate Insurance Co – 71 W Main St – Oyster Bay, NY 11771 – (516) 922-5025
Independent Agents

These agents are not required to write business for one company but instead can place your coverage amongst many companies and possibly get better coverage at lower prices. If your agent finds better pricing, they simply move the coverage in-house and that require little work on your part. When comparing rates, it’s a good idea to get quotes from several independent insurance agents to ensure the widest selection of prices.Most can insure with lesser-known insurance companies which may provide better rates.

Below is a short list of independent insurance agencies in Oyster Bay that are able to give price quote information.

  • Brady Insurance Planning – 18 Spring St – Oyster Bay, NY 11771 – (516) 624-2684
  • Oyster Bay Insurance – 119 Pine Hollow Rd – Oyster Bay, NY 11771 – (516) 922-9131
  • Reardon Raplee Agency – 61 Audrey Ave – Oyster Bay, NY 11771 – (516) 922-6133
  • John Specce Agency Inc – 70 E Main St – Oyster Bay, NY 11771 – (516) 922-1060

To view a complete directory of Oyster Bay insurance agents, simply jump to this page.

Once you have received positive responses to any questions you have and locked in a price quote, chances are good that you have found an insurance agent that is a good match to adequately provide auto insurance.

It’s not one size fits all

When it comes to choosing coverage, there isn’t really a perfect coverage plan. Your needs are not the same as everyone else’s.

Here are some questions about coverages that could help you determine whether your personal situation would benefit from professional advice.

  • Do I need to file an SR-22 for a DUI in New York?
  • Can I get a multi-policy discount for packaging my home and auto coverage?
  • Are split liability limits better than a combined single limit?
  • Am I getting all the discounts available?
  • Should I rate my vehicle as pleasure use or commute?
  • Do all my vehicles need collision coverage?

If you can’t answer these questions but a few of them apply, then you may want to think about talking to a licensed agent.

Keep your options open

Insurance agencies serve a purpose, but you can also buy New York car insurance direct from companies online. Certain companies, such as Farmers Insurance and State Farm, who have local Oyster Bay agents also let you quote and buy online, and online price comparisons are easy if the lowest rate is your goal.

If you’re concerned about not getting advice from an agent when buying direct, this is expected but don’t let that bother you. Online car insurance companies have toll-free phone numbers and other options for getting advice on proper coverages. Consumers also can use live help and 24/7 access that you can use before buying.

Does coverage cost less online? Many people swear by it, but it’s difficult to answer due to the large number of individual components that impact your final bill. It’s a logical assumption that buying direct saves the cost of an agent commission. For most online online companies, however, getting their brand in front of customers is expensive and that impacts the rates consumers pay.

More quotes mean more savings

When shopping online for auto insurance, it’s not a good idea to reduce coverage to reduce premium. Too many times, someone dropped uninsured motorist or liability limits only to find out that the savings was not a smart move. The aim is to get the best coverage possible at an affordable rate while still protecting your assets.

Lower-priced auto insurance can be purchased on the web as well as from independent agents in Oyster Bay, so compare prices from both to get a complete price analysis. Some insurance providers don’t offer the ability to get a quote online and many times these small insurance companies only sell through independent insurance agents.

More tips and info about auto insurance is located at the New York Department of Financial Services website. New York consumers can download brochures, find disaster information, file complaints about a company, and find a variety of consumer forms.

New York agents

The articles below may also help you learn more about auto insurance in Oyster Bay